Lindy’s on 4th’s Lindon Reilly: Expansion, Menu Changes & Getting Healthy

Lindon Reilly at Lindy's on 4th (Credit: Jackie Tran)

Lindy’s on 4th is undergoing a metamorphosis.

For starters, the unconventional burger joint on Fourth Avenue is expanding into former Maya Quetzal space next door. Additions include a 27-foot-long bar featuring 10 beer taps, local beer, local liquor, and possibly a back patio.

“We’re all about supporting local businesses whenever we can,” said Kate Wheat, Reilly’s sister and general manager at Lindy’s on 4th.

Accessibility is also still a priority at Lindy’s.

Arizona Inn – View Menu
Renee’s Organic Oven Pizza
Ghini’s French Cafe – Made With Love 300×250
Boca Tacos Taco Dog
Mama Louisa’s Caprese
Fox – North – Handmade from Scratch

“We’ll have cool drinks with cheap-ass beers,” said Lindon Reilly, owner of his eponymous restaurant Lindy’s. “And milkshakes. I’m stoked.”

No estimated date of completion is available due to ongoing construction. However, the menu is already undergoing changes.

“Everything is moving to being made from scratch,” Reilly said.

Buns are the main exception. Lindy’s Sauce, barbecue sauce, wing sauces, and house pickles will all be made in house.

The pre-formed one-third pound patties are being replaced by larger, hand-formed half-pound patties with a house blend of spices from Mount Hope Wholesale.

Though the menu changes have been in the works for a while, a price increase are due in part to the minimum wage increase.

“If we have to raise prices, we’ll make sure you get the most bang for your buck,” Reilly said.

Since the quality of the ingredients is going up as well, Reilly has been more selective with sourcing for ingredients such as beef.

“I was inspired after working with Ray Flores from Charro Steak,” Reilly said.

Healthier Options

Lindy’s on 4th is shamelessly gluttonous with creations such as the OMFG Burger featuring three pounds of meat and a pound of cheese, forever etched in fame after being featured on the Travel Channel’s Man v. Food with Adam Richman. (Side note: Local competitive eater Michelle Lesco holds the OMFG Burger speed-eating record at just two minutes and twenty-two seconds. She’s  5’4″ and 112 pounds.)

However, Reilly can no longer afford to “get high off his own supply.” Although Reilly had been monitoring his health regularly, one visit revealed a plethora of issues all at once — pneumonia, congestive heart failure, high blood pressure, and diabetes.

“The doctor said if you don’t do something about this, you won’t make it until February,” Reilly said.

He reduced his burger intake, stopped drinking, and had gastric bypass surgery.

“As of today all my ailments are gone and I’m 130 pounds down total so far,” Reilly said.

Donkey Punch Burger at Lindy's on 4th (Credit: Jackie Tran)

Donkey Punch Burger at Lindy’s on 4th (Credit: Jackie Tran)

Although the OMFG Burger and 2 Finger Peekaboo aren’t going anywhere, veggies are getting some more love. Lindy’s will offer more salads and vegetarian options.

An upgraded chicken sandwich is in the works, along with a more fleshed out happy hour menu.

For more information, visit lo4th.com.

Jackie is a food writer and photographer native to Tucson. He enjoys neon-lit dinners and long crab walks on the beach. If you'd like to stalk him, visit jackietran.com
  • Hater

    Changing up a concept that already works is just not smart business. Why change ingredients and raise prices if customers were happy with what they were getting.

    • Kevin P Wolfe

      As it says in the article, Lindy is raising prices in part due to the increase in minimum wage and “If we have to raise prices, we’ll make sure you get the most bang for your buck,”. Businesses have to be able to adapt and that is exactly what he’s doing. I look forward to the changes and hope Lindy continues to be successful in both his business and his health.

      • Hater

        You understand that statement doesn’t make sense. You raise prices to cover new wage but not have more expensive food costs as well. And no need to adapt unless you are struggling in business. That doesn’t seem to be the case so no need to become something different

  • Sergio Lopez

    Props to Lindy on taking steps to improve his health… looking forward to the new menu.