Save the Date 🗓️ Asian Night Market Returns 11/28/2026!Get tickets
Sullivan’s Eatery & Creamery is permanently closing its doors

Sullivan’s Eatery & Creamery is permanently closing its doors

Jun 8, 20221 min read

It’s always a bummer to see local restaurants and businesses close up shop, especially so for a restaurant that’s been open for nearly half a century.

Sullivan’s Eatery & Creamery, which opened 45 years ago on the northwest side, is officially closing its doors at 6444 N. Oracle Rd. The restaurant was originally a Swensen’s and opened up back in 1977.

Sullivan's Eatery & Creamery
Photo courtesy of Sullivan’s Eatery & Creamery on Instagram

The current owner, Alex Mustaffa, has been operating the business since 2017 and recently announced that he’ll be closing in mid-June. More specifically and most recently, the crew at the restaurant is telling folks they will be making the closure official as soon as Friday, June 10 or Saturday, June 11.

So, fans of the restaurant near the corner of Oracle and Orange Grove Road have until the earlier parts of this weekend to have one last meal and a cold scoop of ice cream.

Sullivan's Eatery & Creamery
Photo courtesy of Sullivan’s Eater & Creamery

Heads up, though, because the closing could happen much sooner depending on whether or not the remaining supplies last that long.

One of the reasons for the closure, according to Mustaffa, is the certain business model in the current times. For example, the restaurant, which is a family-friendly restaurant that doesn’t serve alcohol, had steadier foot traffic before the pandemic threw a wrench into the day-to-day workflow.

Sullivan’s Eatery & Creamery is located at 6444 N. Oracle Rd. For more information, call (520) 297-9974 or visit sullivanseateryandcreamery.com.

Article written by:

Matt Sterner

Matt Sterner

More about Matt

At a very young age, Matt Sterner was gifted with the artistic ability to masterfully roll a burrito to the highest of standards, but the wrapped medley of delicious innards wasn’t his first love. Matt’s first true love was a combination of reading, writing, and creating. He grew up reading comics, the ingredients list of his shampoo and conditioner bottles, choose-your-own-adventure books, and the Scrabble dictionary — something he found useful when challenging his grandmother to a game.

He attended college at New Mexico State University and graduated with a degree in Digital Filmmaking. One of his favorite classes was screenwriting because he became responsible for the story’s birth before it came to life on-screen. After school, Matt took on numerous positions at a local television station in Tucson. From dealing out stories about heartbreak to producing “fluffier” content for a lifestyle broadcast, he learned what it takes to adapt to the many emotions the world of media can stir. Since 2017, Matt has dabbled in the culinary world of Tucson as well as San Diego, California from time to time.

If you’re in the mood for strange stories, head over to his pride and joy, wonkytimes.com. And in case you’re curious — yes, after all of this time, he still manages to roll a killer burrito.

Get our free Tucson Foodie weekly newsletter

New openings, events, dish recommendations, and guides — every Wednesday. No spam.

Advertisement

Follow @TucsonFoodie136.5K followers
From washing dishes at 15 to becoming the owner and executive chef, @Nick_avram’s story is rooted in Mount Lemmon and his family’s legacy at @Sawmillrun.

In this Q&A, he discusses his journey, “Mountain Sonoran” cuisine, local sourcing, and what’s ahead for fall. 

Read the full Q&A at Tucsonfoodie.com🌲From washing dishes at 15 to becoming the owner and executive chef, @Nick_avram’s story is rooted in Mount Lemmon and his family’s legacy at @Sawmillrun. In this Q&A, he discusses his journey, “Mountain Sonoran” cuisine, local sourcing, and what’s ahead for fall. Read the full Q&A at Tucsonfoodie.com🌲
@Brickboxbrewery will close its doors Nov. 29. The downtown Tucson taproom at 220 E. Broadway Blvd. announced the news on Instagram. 

“We want to thank all of you that have contributed and shared the space with us over the years,” the brewery wrote. The taproom invites customers to visit over the next month for one last round. 

Full story on Tucsonfoodie.com@Brickboxbrewery will close its doors Nov. 29. The downtown Tucson taproom at 220 E. Broadway Blvd. announced the news on Instagram. “We want to thank all of you that have contributed and shared the space with us over the years,” the brewery wrote. The taproom invites customers to visit over the next month for one last round. Full story on Tucsonfoodie.com
Grant Road construction near Alvernon Way is nearing its end. Crews started in May 2024 and expect to finish October 2026. The finished road will have six lanes, landscaped medians, and buffered bike lanes.

Meanwhile, neighborhood restaurants have kept serving customers through lane shifts and driveway limits. Drivers who avoided the area may have skipped a few favorites. Now that the finish line is in sight, it is a good time to return. Here are four restaurants worth a visit.

@godimsumaz 
@karameloking 
@noodleholicstucson 
@rancheroscarniceriagrant 

More guides on Tucsonfoodie.comGrant Road construction near Alvernon Way is nearing its end. Crews started in May 2024 and expect to finish October 2026. The finished road will have six lanes, landscaped medians, and buffered bike lanes. Meanwhile, neighborhood restaurants have kept serving customers through lane shifts and driveway limits. Drivers who avoided the area may have skipped a few favorites. Now that the finish line is in sight, it is a good time to return. Here are four restaurants worth a visit. @godimsumaz @karameloking @noodleholicstucson @rancheroscarniceriagrant More guides on Tucsonfoodie.com
ONE weekend left to experience Nightfall 2026 at @Oldtucson! ❤️👻

Nightfall runs through October 31. Don’t wait until it’s too late. There’s also plenty to eat and drink while you’re there! 

Vegan tip: You can enjoy pretzels, popcorn, and corn on the cob without mayo 

🎟️Get your tickets now at www.oldtucson.comONE weekend left to experience Nightfall 2026 at @Oldtucson! ❤️👻 Nightfall runs through October 31. Don’t wait until it’s too late. There’s also plenty to eat and drink while you’re there! Vegan tip: You can enjoy pretzels, popcorn, and corn on the cob without mayo 🎟️Get your tickets now at www.oldtucson.com