"A Northern Italian staple, the Tagliatelle al Ragù Emiliano stays faithful to the traditions of Emilia-Romagna with a slow-cooked blend of pork and beef deglazed with red wine for a deep, savory sauce that clings to our house-made tagliatelle." Photo by Isaiah Dahl

"A Northern Italian staple, the Tagliatelle al Ragù Emiliano stays faithful to the traditions of Emilia-Romagna with a slow-cooked blend of pork and beef deglazed with red wine for a deep, savory sauce that clings to our house-made tagliatelle." Photo by Isaiah Dahl

Il Santo Italiano Rustico opens as a regional Italian osteria in Tucson’s Mercado

Tucson Foodie is member-supported. Join the club.

Il Santo Italiano Rustico soft-launched Nov. 6 at Mercado San Agustín in Tucson. The Italian restaurant serves lunch and dinner daily and plans a grand opening Nov. 20.

Co-founders Vito Prencipe and Bonnie Callahan built the menu around regional dishes and traditional ingredients. They describe the restaurant as an osteria guided by the phrase “hospitality as devotion.”

Il Santo interior looking into the bar (Photo by Ernesto Trejo)

A restaurant ready in five weeks

Callahan said the team needed exactly five weeks to prepare the restaurant for opening. She credited staff, partners, and officials at Pima County and the City of Tucson.

The restaurant seats 250 guests inside and out. The interior covers 5,300 square feet, including a 900-square-foot private dining space. A 1,700-square-foot patio adds citrus and string lights.

Prencipe said the name comes from the Mercado itself. Il Santo means “The Saint” in Italian, and the name nods to San Agustín. It also reflects the owners’ view of hospitality as devotion, he said.

Designing an old-world osteria

Callahan said the owners wanted the dining room to feel like an old-world osteria in Italy. “We pictured candlelight, clinking wine glasses, and the smell of amazing food in the air,” she said.

The courtyard shaped that vision. Callahan said the patio and courtyard have long felt familiar, like “a natural gathering spot just like the piazza in Italy where we met.”

Il Santo exterior (Photo by Ernesto Trejo)

Guests can stop for a cocktail and a bite on the courtyard or settle in for dinner. Ryan Trayte designed the branding and website. Callahan said Trayte “more than delivered” on a tight timeline. For wine, the restaurant works with a company called Natural Wine.

The people behind Il Santo

Prencipe grew up in a small town in Puglia, about 13 miles from the Ionian coast. He spent his childhood on his grandparents’ farm, harvesting grapes and olives. The cycle of food on his family’s table gave him respect for seasonal ingredients and the farmers behind them.

He later moved to the Umbrian hill town of Orvieto to study engineering. There, the slow-food culture steered him toward community, sustainability, and traditional agricultural craft.

Callahan is a fifth-generation Tucsonan. Her interest in Italy began in middle school. She majored in Classics and Italian at the University of Arizona.

She spent three semesters in Orvieto through the Arizona in Orvieto study abroad program, where she met Prencipe. After she graduated, the two spent years working with culinary students from around the world and teaching Italian history and language.

During that time, they also co-founded a nonprofit with University of Arizona Italian Studies alumna Tina Waddington. The nonprofit funds study abroad opportunities for underserved students.

Culinary Director Giuliano Fulgheri grew up in Sardinia. He learned the island’s recipes in his family’s kitchen. By age 13, he worked in local Sardinian restaurants. He later trained at a fine-dining restaurant in northern Italy.

Callahan said the three share an interest in the history, traditions, and people behind each dish.

Regional cooking and local sourcing

Prencipe said Il Santo focuses on producers and ingredients tied to traditional Italian cooking. “Every dish represents a region of Italy,” he said.

The restaurant buys flour from southern Italy, where the winter climate suits durum wheat. For cured meats, Il Santo partners with an Italian family in Southern California that follows methods from Italy.

Prencipe said Southern Italian cooking relies on durum wheat, olive oil, tomatoes, and coastal seafood. Those staples anchor the kitchen. Because the team comes from Puglia, Sardinia, and kitchens trained in northern Italy, the menu also draws from across the peninsula.

Pizza and pasta made in-house

The pizza crust follows the Napoletano style and measures 10 to 12 inches. The kitchen uses Tipo 1 flour from Italy. Cooks ferment the dough for 48 to 72 hours with a house-cultured mother yeast.

The pizza list runs from the Margherita at $15 to the Mare and Puglia at $20. Mare tops Italian crema with calamari, mussels, and shrimp. Puglia adds burrata, prosciutto, and wild arugula.

"The Margherita pizza is crafted with Type 1 flour and San Marzano tomatoes from the area of Naples, and finished with fior di latte mozzarella." Photo by Isaiah Dahl

Cooks make all pasta in-house daily, except the gluten-free option. For that, Il Santo uses La Molisana, a fourth-generation Italian pastificio dating to 1912. The owners said the company extrudes its pasta through bronze dies and that it cooks al dente.

Bigoli anchors the pasta list. The owners chose the thick, chewy noodle as a classic workhorse for the regional recipes they cook. They said it also holds sauce well. Bigoli appears in the carbonara, the amatriciana, and the cacio e pepe.

Gluten-free bread, pasta, or pizza crust costs $3 more on request. The owners said guests with dietary restrictions should “still get thoughtful, delicious options.”

What is on the “A First Taste” menu

The opening menu groups dishes into five categories:

  • Antipasti, $15 to $20: Il Santo Board, gnocco fritto, carpaccio di verdure, and fritto misto

  • Salads, $10 to $14: insalata mista, finocchi e arancia, and rucola, pere e gorgonzola

  • Pizza, $15 to $20: seven pizzas, including a seasonal vegetable pie

  • Pasta, $19 to $21: bigoli alla carbonara, tagliatelle al ragù, bigoli alla amatriciana, and cacio e pepe

  • Entrées, $25 to $38: vitello alla Milanese, tagliata di manzo, and pollo arrosto

The owners named the Il Santo Board, carbonara, and vitello alla Milanese as signature dishes. The $20 board holds sliced cured meats, assorted cheeses, raspberry-chili jam, focaccia barese, and local honey. The $38 vitello pairs a breaded veal cutlet with saffron risotto alla Milanese and a red wine reduction.

"Inspired by the classic Sicilian citrus salad, our Finocchi e Arancia salad tosses shaved fennel and fresh orange supremes with quinoa, toasted amaranth, and a bright blood orange vinaigrette." Photo by Isaiah Dahl

For the $17 fritto misto, guests choose between two versions. Mare includes calamari and shrimp with lemon-herb aioli. Terra includes fried peppers, carrots, zucchini, and mozzarelline with salsa contadina.

Cocktails, wine, and beer

The drink menu lists 12 cocktails from $14 to $18, plus a $12 house red sangria. The Canto XIV Margarita combines Astral reposado tequila, Sicilian Solerno liqueur, and blood orange. Il Santissimo mixes brown-butter infused bourbon, amaretto, espresso, and citrus foam.

The wine list offers 29 wines by the glass, priced from $8 to $17. Bottles start at $30. Selections span Italian regions such as Puglia, Sicily, Tuscany, Piedmont, and Veneto.

"The wine list balances iconic Italian producers with small-batch natural wines, always prioritizing quality and sustainability. Anchoring the reserve side of our list are the Super Tuscans, including Sassicaia, the landmark Bolgheri wine that started the Super Tuscan movement." Photo by Isaiah Dahl

Four beers pour from draught, and nine more come in bottles and cans. Prices range from $6 to $10. Non-alcoholic options include a sparkling Riesling and Peroni 0.0. Superstition Meadery’s Crystal Sail mead carries a gluten-free label.

A menu for kids

The kids menu lists eight items from $3 to $13. Options include a breaded chicken cutlet, a burger, fried mozzarella, a personal pizza, and pasta with butter and Parmigiano Reggiano or tomato sauce. A scoop of gelato costs $3.

If you go

  • Location: Mercado San Agustín, 100 S. Avenida del Convento, Tucson

  • Hours: 11 a.m.-9 p.m. daily

  • Grand opening: Nov. 20

  • Prices: $10 and up on the main menu

  • Phone: 520-777-7612

The owners plan to add breakfast hours with traditional Italian pastries. Prencipe described the goal as “a neighborhood gathering spot where you’re welcomed like family.”

Article written by:

Jackie Tran

Jackie Tran is a Tucson-based food writer and photographer. Best known locally for his work for Tucson Foodie, his work has also appeared in publications such as Bon Appétit, National Geographic, and the New York Times.

Outside of food, he also loves playing musical instruments and petting pets.

If you’d like to stalk him, visit his Instagram @jackie_tran_ or jackietran.com.

Get our free Tucson Foodie weekly newsletter

New openings, events, dish recommendations, and guides — every Wednesday. No spam.

Advertisement

Follow @TucsonFoodie137.1K followers
Who would you give a free year of the Tucson Foodie Club to?

This Black Friday, buy a year of membership and give a year to someone you love.

$200 · Ends Monday, Nov. 30
Tucsonfoodie.com/membershipWho would you give a free year of the Tucson Foodie Club to? This Black Friday, buy a year of membership and give a year to someone you love. $200 · Ends Monday, Nov. 30 Tucsonfoodie.com/membership
FREE NIGHT MARKET

@Vegantucsonnightmarket returns December 5th from 6-9 pm at Rillito Park! Bring a blanket to donate to @Ironwoodpigsanctuary and wear your ugliest holiday sweater.

Come support our amazing local makers, small businesses, and restaurants while eating an absolutely ridiculous amount of vegan food. 

Music by @visionaryhousecollective 
Glamour shots by @viguerrafoto 
Caricature’s by @snickerdoodlesllc 

🌙FREE ENTRY | FREE PARKING | DOG-FRIENDLY
📍RILLITO PARK • 4502 N 1ST AVE, TUCSON, AZFREE NIGHT MARKET @Vegantucsonnightmarket returns December 5th from 6-9 pm at Rillito Park! Bring a blanket to donate to @Ironwoodpigsanctuary and wear your ugliest holiday sweater. Come support our amazing local makers, small businesses, and restaurants while eating an absolutely ridiculous amount of vegan food. Music by @visionaryhousecollective Glamour shots by @viguerrafoto Caricature’s by @snickerdoodlesllc 🌙FREE ENTRY | FREE PARKING | DOG-FRIENDLY 📍RILLITO PARK • 4502 N 1ST AVE, TUCSON, AZ
Don’t take our word for it.

@Colby.elliott has been a Tucson Foodie member since day one (literally, member 1). Jennifer says the best part is the people she’s met and the friends she’s made along the way.

This Black Friday, buy a year of membership and give a year to someone you love.

$200 · Ends Monday, Nov. 30
Join or gift at tucsonfoodie.com/membershipDon’t take our word for it. @Colby.elliott has been a Tucson Foodie member since day one (literally, member 1). Jennifer says the best part is the people she’s met and the friends she’s made along the way. This Black Friday, buy a year of membership and give a year to someone you love. $200 · Ends Monday, Nov. 30 Join or gift at tucsonfoodie.com/membership
Guide to Chinese noodles in Tucson:

@bamboonoodlehouseaz 
@fatman.kitchen 
Kung Fu Noodle 
@noodleholicstucson 
@jewelsnoodlekitchen 

Tucsonfoodie.comGuide to Chinese noodles in Tucson: @bamboonoodlehouseaz @fatman.kitchen Kung Fu Noodle @noodleholicstucson @jewelsnoodlekitchen Tucsonfoodie.com