On a Friday morning, I received a call from chef David Solórzano of the soon-to-open Lucky Penny BBQ (they're hoping for Nov. 30).
"Hey, where do you think has the best flour tortillas in town?" he asked.
"Tortilleria Doña Esperanza is my favorite for making burritos at home," I said. "But I know Tortillas Bryan is another recent local favorite and also very good. I've been meaning to write an article on the different tortillas in town. Wanna go taste a bunch of them next week with me?"

And our tortilla tasting tour began. While local classics such as La Estrella Bakery Inc and Alejandro's Tortilla Factory are often available at grocery stores, we wanted to check out the prominent options near Lucky Penny. As it turns out, four notable local tortilla factories reside within a mile of each other in South Tucson—less than a 15-minute walk.

First, Tortillas Don Juan (the building says Tortilleria Don Juan, but we're going with the name on the tortilla packaging).

We walked inside and into the carniceria section, where the piles of packaged tortillas stacked neatly in rows. We asked when to visit for the fresh, hot tortillas—the cashier said they make them all day. However, they wait until the tortillas cool before packing them so they don't get humid and sticky. She went to the back and brought us one freshly made tortilla for us to enjoy in the moment.

INGREDIENTS: Wheat Flour (Niacin, Reduced Iron, Thiamin Mononitrate, Riboflavin, Enzyme, Folic Acid), Water, Canola Oil, Salt, Calcium Propionate, Milk, Non stick.
The ingredient label reveals canola oil as the fat of choice, augmented with a little milk. Calcium propionate acts as a preservative.
Next, we headed to Tortillas Bryan a block away. Note: they only accept cash. A few people were already lined up with multiple packs of tortillas each. The kitchen was visible, complete with a bucket of margarine/butter ready for smothering over a fresh tortilla.

Ingredients: Wheat Flour, Water, Shortening, Salt, Milk, Non Stick.
Here, shortening is the fat of choice. Also notable: no preservatives, so store the tortillas in the refrigerator.
Third, we went from South Fourth Avenue over to South Third Avenue to visit Tortillas de Harina Linda. The room was filled with boxes of tortillas that they ship up to Phoenix.

INGREDIENTS: WHEAT FLOUR, SALT, WATER, SHORTENING.
Like Tortillas Bryan, shortening and no preservatives. But no milk.
Finally, we visited Tortilleria Doña Esperanza. This small space also features corn tortillas and vegan oat tortillas. Without stepping from the entrance, you can see the conveyor belt where the fresh tortillas cool before packaging.

Ingredients: Unbleached Wheat Flour, Water, Lard and Beef Shortening, Cottonseed Oil, Salt, Dry Milk, Mono & Diglycerides, CMC Gum, Calcium Propionate (a preservative).
The ingredients for the flour tortillas here reveal unbleached flour and a blend of fats: lard, beef shortening, and cottonseed oil. The remaining ingredients help as conditioners and preservation, though I still recommend storing these in the fridge if you don't eat them all the same day.
Before the tasting, these ranked as my personal favorites for burritos thanks to their pliability and richer flavor.
With four piles of flour tortillas in hand, David and I head back to Lucky Penny. I set up a blind tasting and we tasted our way through, scoring on each tortilla on flavor and texture.

One tortilla stood out the most in testing. It handled with pliability without being too flaky. The salt level was just right. The spotting was scattered without being too burnt or blond. And it had a soft amber translucence.
While all of the tortillas easily surpass the leavened, mass-produced national brands, we had one winner during this tasting: Tortillas Bryan.
Turns out we agree with the popular vote on this one. However, with all tortilla factories so close to each other, consider swinging by all four and deciding for yourself which one you like best. You'll end up spending around only $20 and tasty tortillas for weeks.














